The Associated Press’s Seth Borenstein, his wire service, and most of the globaloney-advocating establishment press have a problem.
Peter Gleick, described in a related UK Guardian story as “a water scientist and president of the Pacific Institute,” said last week that he “obtained” documents from the Heartland Institute about its strategy to, in part and in Borenstein’s words, (from his 1,000-word dispatch), “teach schoolchildren skepticism about global warming.” Now, Gleick has admitted that he stole them (Gleick’s description: “I solicited and received additional materials directly … under someone else’s name”). Oops. It get worse for Borenstein and the wire service on at least two levels.
First, Heartland claims, with others’ support, that a key two-page “2012 Heartland Climate Strategy” memo Gleick posted is a fake. Heartland’s contention seems reasonable to cap-and-trade supporter Megan McArdle at the Atlantic. McArdle listed seven good reasons to doubt the memo’s authenticity and followed that enumeration with a “section-by-section analysis of what makes me uncomfortable.” Friday afternoon, Ross Kaminsky at the American Spectator wrote that “all evidence so far supports Heartland’s emphatic assertion that the document is a forgery.” There is heavy suspicion is that Gleick himself wrote it.
(more…)